15 Best Toys for Border Collies 2021 – Latest Reviews

If there is one dog breed that offers the perfect combination of energy and intelligence, it is the border collie. This breed is so active that it was in the past used in herding cattle, and it never disappointed.

The canine is also quite smart, and this makes it easier to train and give instructions.

Therefore, it is wise that you find the appropriate dog toy that would stimulate his mind plus give him an avenue to burn off his energy. If not, they may turn their attention to your furniture, and this may lead to huge losses.

If you want to get the best toys for border collies, you should know where to start. For instance, what should you look out for?

Well, this article aims to answer this and other questions for you regarding dog toys for border collies.

Best Toys for Border Collies

Top-Rated Border Collie Toys: Comparison List

First, we shall start by reviewing some models of dog toys which we believe are the best in the market. Here’s a short comparison preceding our detailed reviews.

1ZippyPaws – Woodland Friends Burrow14 x 6 x 6 inches11.2 ounces
2KONG – Wobbler – Interactive Treat Dispensing Dog Toy7.5 x 5.1 x 5.1 inches30.4 ounces
3ChuckIt! Ultra Ball, Medium2.5 x 2.5 x 2.5 inches8 ounces
4KONG 41938 Classic Dog Toy4 x 2.8 x 2.8 inches7.8 ounces
5Our Pets Smarter Toys IQ Treat Ball4.4 x 4 x 4 inches4.3 ounces
6Starmark Bob-A-Lot Interactive Pet Toy6 x 6 x 8.5 inches25.6 ounces
7Aerobie 28C12 Dogobie Disc Outdoor Flying Disc for Dogs8 x 8 x 0.75 inches1.44 Ounces
8Trixie Chess Game, Level 315.75 x 10.5 x 3.75 inches46.72 ounces
9Chuckit! Ball Launcher Classic Medium
10Pacific Pups Products supporting pacificpuprescue.com dog rope toys12.99 x 9.8 x 3.35 inches39.84 ounces
11Outward Hound Tail Teaser Dog Flirt Pole Toy36.61 x 2.36 x 7.48 inches5.6 Ounces
12ZippyPaws – Original Donutz No Stuffing Squeaky Plush Dog Toy 7 x 7 x 2 inches2.24 Ounces
13West Paw Zogoflex Qwizl Dog Puzzle Treat Toy1.97 x 5.31 x 1.97 inches5.64 Ounces
14Outward Hound Nina Ottosson Dog Tornado Puzzle Toy11 x 7.5 x 3.25 inches24.32 ounces
15Outward Hound Nina Ottosson Puzzle Toy for Dogs 14.5 x 11.75 x 2 inches35.84 ounces

1. Zippy Paws Woodland Friends Burrow Dog Toy

Considering how active Border Collies are, you need a toy that can keep your dog engaged. Zippy Paws Woodland Friends Burrow seems like a good choice as it has three chipmunks and a burrow where they hide for your pet to search.

The chipmunks on this toy make a squeaking sound when squeezed. These squeaks are likely to excite your dog and at the same time arouse their curiosity.

For safety purposes, the toy is made from soft material that is gentle on the dog’s teeth to ensure their dental safety. However, this material is unsuitable for aggressive chewers as it might get torn after several months of use.


  • Safe for teeth
  • Ideal size
  • Easy to clean
  • Squeaking sound


  • Unsuitable for aggressive chewers

2. KONG Wobbler Treat Dispensing Toy

What about having a toy that keeps your Border Collies entertained and at the same time, satisfied? Well, try out the KONG Wobbler toy that can dispense treats at playtime and help your dog remain energized.

Cleaning and refilling the toy is simple as you just need to unscrew it to fill up or clean it, then screw it back on. In addition, the toy’s movements are unpredictable, which is good for play and entertainment.

This seems like a good toy but the dispensing hole is large and cannot be adjusted to let out a small number of treats. Some customers have reported that their pets’ paws got stuck in the hole and this can cause injury to the dog.


  • Simple to clean
  • Easy to refill
  • Dispenses treats
  • Unpredictable movement


  • Large dispensing hole

3. Chuckit! Ultra Ball Dog Toy

Looking for a ball toy for your Border Collie? Look no further as this Chuck it Ultra Ball is designed to float on water, making it suitable for aquatic games and it also bounces well for jumping games with your dog.

This ball is available in four different sizes, giving you a chance to select a ball that your dog can hold with its mouth. Getting the right size helps to prevent accidents during play.

The ball is made of rubber that is alleged to be durable. However, some pets manage to make holes in the ball and the rubber pieces are hazardous when ingested since they can get stuck in your Border Collies’ throat.


  • Durable material
  • Floats in water
  • Bounces well
  • Different sizes


  • Choking hazard

4. KONG Classic Dog Toy

Pick a KONG classic toy from the six different sizes provided and keep your Border Collie occupied with different activities. This ball can bounce; therefore, it is a good choice for jump and catch dog games.

Put your dog’s favorite treats in the toy and let your dog have fun by engaging in rewarding physical games. This food-dispensing toy can be used to help check your dog’s weight by improving their eating habits.

This toy is made of rubber which is supposed to enhance its durability. Unfortunately, some customers have reported that their Border Collies managed to snap the toy in two as they tried to get the food inside it.


  • Varied sizes
  • Dispenses food
  • Bouncy toy
  • Dishwasher safe


  • Not durable

5. OurPets IQ Treat Ball Interactive Dog Toy

Help your furry friend to get smarter as they play with this interactive toy by adjusting the desired difficulty level using the ball’s adjustable interior disc. Your Border Collies will learn how to roll the ball in a way to get the treats dispensed.

Mental stimulation is encouraged while they exercise and they get to notice that more play results in more treats. The ball is available in 3 inches size for smaller dogs and 4 inches for larger canines.

One drawback we found with the toy is that the dispensing hole is a hazard. The pets get their paws into the hole while trying to reach the treats and their paws get stuck.


  • Adjustable interior disc
  • Easy to clean
  • Available in two sizes
  • Dispenses treats


  • Hazardous dispensing hole

6. StarMark Bob-A-Lot Dog Toy

Arouse your dog’s curiosity with this toy that is designed to wobble and keep your doggie’s mind active as it tries to figure out how the toy works. Furthermore, your Border Collie gets rewarded for figuring out how the toy works.

You can determine the amount of treat your dog gets using the adjustable toy openings. This helps to prevent wastage of the treats or your dog overfeeding during play.

The toy is made of plastic to prevent it from injuring the pet’s teeth. Unfortunately, the plastic, according to some customers, cannot withstand dogs with aggressive chewing habits.


  • Anti-slip bottom
  • Wobbling design
  • Adjustable openings
  • Gentle on teeth


  • Unsuitable for aggressive chewers

7. AerobieDogobie Flying Disc for Dogs

Have you been searching for a toy that your Border Collie is unlikely to destroy within the first week of using it? Try out this flying disc that is made of tear-resistant material to enhance its durability and ensure your dog has fun.

According to the manufacturer, the disc is designed for easy grip by mouth when it is in motion. Besides that, it is unlikely to cause injury to your dog’s mouth and teeth as the materials used are safe.

This seems like a good toy to keep your pet running and panting around as they have fun and burn away calories. As such, it is for outdoor use since space is needed for it to fly and where your dog can run as it chases the disc.


  • Tear-resistant
  • Durable toy
  • Gentle on teeth
  • Easy to grip


  • Outdoor use only

8. Trixie Chess Game Pet Products

Challenge your Border Collie with this chess game to help stimulate their mental capabilities and brain development. The toy has four challenging levels and it has a compartment for treats to keep your dog searching.

The rubber base ensures the board is stable as your dog moves the cones and hollows. In addition, there is a booklet included which we recommend you go through for guidance and to ensure that you are using the toy to the maximum.

Some customers who purchased this toy found the size too small for their Border Collies. The parts can fit in their mouths; this is unsafe since it can be easily ingested.


  • Rubber base
  • Durable plastic
  • Easy to clean
  • Training booklet included


  • Suitable for small dogs only

9. Chuckit! Sport Launcher Dog Toy

Use this ball launcher to throw the ball far to make your Border Collie run and exercise their body. The launcher is said to be easy to use with a flexible handle for efficient launching.

There are seven different sizes of this Sport Launcher for you to pick from, depending on the distance you want to throw the ball. A tennis ball is also included that is compatible with the launcher so you are set for playtime.

This launcher is portable, meaning you can go with it anywhere and have your Border Collies fetch the ball. You have to watch out for fakes since some customers complained that the products they received failed to launch the balls since they were faulty.


  • Many sizes to choose from
  • Portable
  • Easy to use
  • Durable material


  • Faulty launcher

10. Pacific Pups Products Dog Toys

Get your Border Collies this variety of toys and engage them in unending fun activities. There are ropes of different sizes that can be good for interactive play which enhances pet bonding.

The giraffe and carrot floss included in the pack is to help clean your dog’s teeth by eliminating plaque. Besides that, the flossers assist to strengthen your dog’s teeth as they chew on them, which is a good practice, especially for puppies.

Unfortunately, some customers have complained that the ropes are made from low-quality materials. As such, aggressive chewers tear them apart and the small parts can be ingested, leading to indigestion or choking.


  • Gentle on teeth
  • Variety of toys
  • Giraffe floss included
  • Easy to clean


  • Low-quality materials

11. Outward Hound Tail Teaser Dog Toy

Enhance your dog’s hunting instincts with this toy from Outward Hound. The tail teaser has a squeak and rattle that are meant to mimic a natural prey to help stimulate your Border Collies’ hunting instincts while they run around for a healthy, well-tones body.

You can use this toy both outside and inside to help you bond more with your furry friend. This seems like a good option for a dog toy, especially when the weather is unfavorable for outdoor activities, as your pet can still have their daily exercise.

The fur lures encourage your dog to chase and catch. However, they are made of fur which tends to disintegrate in case it gets wet from your dog’s saliva, causing it to stick on the tongue or irritate the throat.


  • Durable cord
  • Outdoor and indoor use
  • For all dog sizes
  • Easy to play with


  • Fur lures are hazardous

12. Zippy Paws Donutz Squeaky Dog Toy

The flavored donut-shaped toy seems like an ideal toy for your Border Collie to keep their mouth busy and away from your stuff. In addition, the squeaks are likely to arouse the pet’s curiosity.

This toy is designed with no stuffing on the inside to prolong its use. In addition, the size of the toy makes it useable for dogs of all sizes and you can also carry it anywhere.

Some customers raised concerns about the plastic beads found inside the toy. These beads can choke when accidentally ingested, in case the toy is torn apart, meaning you have to supervise your dog’s playtime for safety reasons.


  • For all dog sizes
  • Simple to clean
  • Squeaking sound
  • Flavored toy


  • Dangerous plastic beads

13. West Paw ZogoflexQwizl Toy for Dogs

Do you wish to engage your dog in aquatic activities but are yet to find the toy to use? West Paw ZogoflexQwizl toy can float, making it probably one of the most suitable toys for your dog to play within the pool.

You can put a treat in the toy for your dog to try and get. The toy can also be tossed to have your dog run and fetch it, which keeps their muscles strong.

This toy, according to the manufacturer, is for chewing. Some of the customers who purchased it had to deal with their Border Collies vomiting after chewing and ingesting parts of the toy.


  • Floats in water
  • Dispenses treats
  • Available in two sizes
  • Outdoor and indoor use


  • Ingested pieces may cause vomiting

14. Outward Hound Nina Ottosson Tornado Dog Game

Challenge your Border Collie to find treats in the twelve compartments on this dog puzzle. This helps to stimulate their mental skills while keeping them away from destroying your items like chewing or scratching the seats.

This toy is simple to clean to prevent your dog from ingesting dirt. Furthermore, the toy can be used by more than one dog for more fun and bonding.

On the flip side, the toy does not close properly once you put the treats into the compartments. As such, some customers who purchased it had to send it back since it was not working as required and their dogs could not play with it.


  • Simple to clean
  • Treat compartments
  • Durable material
  • Mind stimulating


  • Malfunctional

15. Outward Hound Nina Ottosson Puzzle Toy

Is your Border Collie an aggressive chewer? This Outward Hound Nina Ottosson Puzzle toy seems like a good option since it is made to withstand chewing as it is in one piece with no small hazardous parts that can choke your dog.

There are seven treat compartments with sliding cups and flaps to keep your dog busy. The toy is easily cleanable by hand to prevent germs-related illnesses.

Some customers expressed disappointment since the puzzle was too easy for their Border Collies. They were able to figure out how the toy works and got the treats very fast, making the game boring and non-interactive.


  • No choking parts
  • Easy to wash
  • Durable construction
  • Seven treat compartments


  • Not challenging

The Buying Guide: How to Choose

If you want the ideal dog toy that would serve you effectively, there are several factors that you have to consider. Let’s check them out.


The material that is used in making a toy will determine how long it holds up in the face of constant biting and chewing by the pooch. Ideally, rubber and nylon tend to last longer as compared to plastic.


The perfect toy should be large enough for comfortable carrying around and tossing. On the other hand, it should not be too small such that it becomes a choking hazard.


These noisemakers have the effect of raising your pet’s curiosity and thereby encouraging him to play more. However, be watchful that these items do not come out and choke the dog.


An ideal toy should be easy to maintain by placing it in the dishwasher or washing machine.


Above all, keep in mind what your dog is usually comfortable with. Note that this may override some of the factors we have discussed above.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

We came across some queries during our research for the best toys for border collies. Below are some of their expert responses.

Is it normal for my border collie to suddenly stop playing with his toys?

Yes, it is. It may be due to health issues that need the attention of the vet. On the other hand, it may be that the pet is bored and needs new toys.

Which types of dog toys are available in the market?

When it comes to types of dog toys, you have five different options to choose from. They include interactive toys, plush toys, fetch toys, chew toys, and rope n tug toys. How you select them depends on your pet’s unique needs.

What should I look out for if I want to land the best item?

The factors to consider as you shop for the best toy for your border collie include its durability, ease-of-maintenance, size, your pooch’s preference, your budget, among others.

Best Overall Choice

Our best toy for Border Collies is Zippy Paws Woodland Friends Burrow dog toy which is gentle on your dog’s teeth. In addition, the squeaking sound can keep any Border Collies entertained and busy for hours.

Final Thoughts

With all that information in mind, you should have an easy time next time you go shopping for the ideal toy for your border collie. Remember to keep the pet’s safety on top of your list by checking the toy for any hazardous content.

Leave a Comment